Ethylene or Propylene Glycol? A Heat Transfer Fluid Guide
Ethylene Glycol-Based Heat Transfer Fluid
It offers higher heat transfer efficiency and is preferred in industrial cooling/heating systems (chillers, boilers, process equipment), heat pumps, heat recovery systems and leak detection equipment. However, it is toxic — it must not be used in environments with food contact. METOX Antifrozen (N) prevents freezing and inhibits the formation of scale and corrosion.
Propylene Glycol-Based Heat Transfer Fluid
It is designed for food-contact environments such as food and beverage production plants (breweries, dairies, ice cream factories, cold stores, fish processing plants) and pharmaceutical factories — it is non-toxic. METOX Antifrozen (L) meets this need with its transparent formulation; it is also approved as an antifreeze filling fluid for sprinkler fire extinguishing systems.
Which One Should I Choose?
If your system does not come into contact with food/pharmaceutical production, ethylene glycol (N) is more economical and efficient. If there is a risk of contact, propylene glycol (L) is mandatory.
Technical Properties of METOX Antifrozen (N)
METOX Antifrozen (N) is a clear, transparent liquid based on monoethylene glycol (MEG). At 20 °C, its density is approximately 1.11 g/cm³, its boiling point 166 °C and its pH value approximately 8.5 (tested according to DIN 51757 and ASTM D 1120). Its corrosion inhibitor package contains no nitrite, amine, borate, silicate or phosphate; it is formulated without carcinogenic/mutagenic/reprotoxic (CMR) substances. The minimum use concentration is 20% by volume (providing freeze protection to −9/−10 °C), and it is suitable for continuous service temperatures from −50 °C to +150 °C. The product is manufactured under the DIN EN ISO 9001 quality system.
Technical Properties of METOX Antifrozen (L)
METOX Antifrozen (L) is a transparent liquid based on 1,2-monopropylene glycol (MPG). At 20 °C, its density is approximately 1.043 g/cm³, its boiling point 155 °C and its pour point −58 °C. The minimum use concentration is 25% by volume (freeze protection to −10 °C), and it is suitable for continuous service temperatures from −25 °C to +150 °C. It is produced according to the same corrosion inhibitor principles (free of nitrite/amine/borate/silicate/phosphate, CMR-free) and is covered by the DIN EN ISO 9001 quality system.
Freeze Protection by Area of Use
Both products offer different freeze protection ranges depending on the area of use. METOX Antifrozen (N) provides freeze protection of −10/−20 °C in hot water heating systems, −10/−15 °C in circuits combined with heat pumps, −10/−40 °C in cooling systems and −20 °C as a leak detection fluid. METOX Antifrozen (L), on the other hand, offers protection in the range of −10/−40 °C in cooling circuits, −20/−25 °C in circuits combined with heat pumps and −10/−15 °C in ground-coupled circuits. The correct concentration should be selected according to the lowest ambient temperature to which the system will be exposed — both products must always be used diluted with water, and the dilution water must not contain more than 100 mg/kg of chloride.
Corrosion Protection and Material Compatibility
The corrosion-inhibiting effectiveness of both products is continuously verified according to the ASTM D 1384 standard (88 °C, 6 litres of air/hour, test durations of 336 and 3,000 hours). The test results show significantly lower weight loss on copper, brass, steel, cast iron and aluminium compared with uninhibited glycol/water mixtures. For example, while a corrosion loss of −152 g/m² is measured on steel after 3,000 hours in an uninhibited ethylene glycol mixture, this value falls to −0.5 g/m² with METOX Antifrozen (N). Care must be taken that the systems contain no galvanised pipes or zinc-containing parts, and the products must not be mixed with other Antifrozen products or with products from other manufacturers.
Points to Note When Changing Over a System
If a system previously operated with a salt-based coolant or with water only is to be switched to METOX Antifrozen products, the system must first be flushed thoroughly — otherwise salt and rust residues may impair the product's corrosion-inhibiting effect. Drained systems should be refilled within a few days, and the system should be kept full during the waiting period so that no risk of corrosion arises at the liquid/air phase boundary. When filling, about two thirds of the water should be added first, followed by the product; a fully homogeneous mixture is achieved within a few days by running the system. Small leaks may become more noticeable after the changeover because the product has a lower surface tension than water — in this case, if tightening the connections is not sufficient, the line concerned should be drained and the seals replaced.
Related Product
METOX ANTIFROZEN (N)
You can request MSDS and TDS documents from our technical documents page.